There are some romantic comedy movies that transcend the genre they inhabit. Such is the case with "As Good as It Gets" (1997: directed by James L. Brooks, story and screenplay by Mark Andrus). I re-watched this film three time in the last two weeks, and I still marvel at how good it is. This movie excels on several different fronts, is unafraid to be controversial, and actually transcends the genre and attempts to actually deal with real life issue. I am going to laud a lot of praise on this film, and on several different fronts -- and this has nothing to do with the fact that both leads in this film, Jack Nicholson and Helen Hunt won Oscars for their roles as Melvin Udall and Carol Connelly. "As Good as It Gets" was also nominated for best picture of the year, but lost out to James Cameron's "Titanic".
So what makes "As Good as It Gets" so good? Let's ignore the obvious, great acting performances turned in by Jack Nicholson and Helen Hunt. No need to really elaborate more on that as both were honored with Oscars for the work they turned in.
Story wise I la-oved how they handled the bigoted, mean-spirited loner against the sensitive, gay artist neighbor. Greg Kinnear was great as the gay artist neighbor Simon. I especially liked how writer Mark Andrus chose to give us additional information about Simeon late, ie. how he get the way he got from a confrontation he had with his father. Very well handled. Who says rom-com's can't deal with issues? This one deals with Melvin Udall learning how befriend someone who's ideal and morality is complete than anything he's used too. Catch this because it's deep. Melvin's character is facilitated by him taking in the gay neighbors dog. This is the catalyst that sparks change in the protagonist. By loving Verdell, Simeon's dog, Melvin learns he NEEDS PEOPLE; he needs to interact and be part of society, not just a lonely writer cracking out novels.
I thought the "gay" angle was handled brilliantly by the writers, director and actors in this movie. And I'm not pro-homosexual by any stretch of the imagination. But in seeing how Melvin and Carol interact with Simeon, you get to the human side of an active gay person, and realize they're just people too with real hurts in their lives like the rest of us.
I, E.C. Henry, do not a gay bone in my body. I'm 100% heterosexual. I grew up in a time and place where homosexually shunned, and people suspected as being gay were routinely picked on and made fun of. The truth of the matter is, I've never really hung out with gay people, men or women. One time while I was living in Boise, Idaho I meet a guy in church and we hung out together. I thought we were just being friends, but after taking him to hot spring I liked to frequent in the mountains just outside of Boise the guy told me he like me--sexually!! THAT jarred me. But I tastefully told that guy I had no interest in that, but that I was interested in him helping me get set-up with this hottie girl he was friends with. Didn't fly, the gay guy didn't help me out, and after that we stopped doing things together and I like he moved away. Weird, hug? Meeting a guy through church who turns out to be gay--and ends up hitting on you! Strange takeaway message there, but I digress...
This movie, "As Good as It Gets" also has a very solid theme. Looking back at that post I made on rom-com themes back in April of 2013, I see back then I stated the theme of "As Good as It Gets" as being, love can cause growth and a broader life to be experienced by even the most crustiest of curmudgeons. And this is surely true when you consider Melvin Udall's character arc. But now watching it these two more times I found a similar character arc with Carol Connelly, the waitress that Melvin takes a liking too. Only Carol's character arc is about acknowledging her own need for love and living a broader life then just existing to be an emergcy nurse for her sickly son.
What I'm getting at here is that Melvin and Carol have similar character arcs. Both are missing something, and don't realize it at first. But when Melvin takes in Simeon's dog, he comes to the realization, he needs someone in his life. Then their is the key moment in the movie where Carol and her mother talk,and Carol pours out her heart and lamments the fact that she had ill-thoughts of a couple in love she saw on the bus. With her son getting better, Carol now starts looking at herself and comes to the realization that she too needs love, love from a man.
The chemical equation of these two characters, Melvin Udall and Carol Connelly is one of the best I've ever seen. Maybe the best chemical equation for two leads in a romantic comedy of all-time. So what do I even mean when bringing up this term, "chemical equation". Well-p, Skippy, I can't claim ownership of this term, chemical equation, actually I'm using the very same term Billy Mernit introduces us to his his AWESOME book, "Writing the Romantic Comedy" which you can by buy here via Amazon link, which after you read you'll know what I'm talking about... Okay, so for the purpose of this post I'll bring you up to speed, what Billy is referring to in a romantic comedy's "chemical equation" is the set-up with both participants in a potential romantic coupling go into at the start of the odyssey of their foray into a romance with each other. Chemical equation = pre-romance set-up, i.e. the state of mind and where both people are coming from.
Melvin is a reclusive writer who is mean-spirited and disliked my most everyone he runs into. Carol is a down-to-earth realist who like Melvin lives a small life on a seemingly endless cycle of tending to the ongoing medical needs of her son. What I like about the chemical equation about these two is the way after they are established Mark Andrus' story fleshes out their inner need to be loved. Melvin's issues are titanic in nature, Carol's not so much. Melvin loves Carol but is so self-centered he can't see it. But in helping out his gay neighbor, Simon, through a very rough time in his life, Melvin gets to interact with Carol in a different way outside of the restaurant she works at, and eventually Carol comes around to the possibility of Melvin being the love interest that she is now aware of that she needs.
What I'm getting at is that Melvin and Carol are two clearly defined characters that you're kinda curious about how a romance could be struck between them. The story is kinda irrelevant. Like say you did character bios on both Carol and Melvin. The chemical equation comes into play when you START considering the plot point of a potential romance between these two. What would that look like? Fascinating spot from which to begin, and it's all character based, based on what writer Mark Andrus chooses to tell us about both characters.
So in summary, here's what "As Good as Gets" does right:
- Powerhouse performances by its leads: Jack Nicholson as Melvin Udall, Hellen Hunt as Carol Connelly. And one of greatest supporting actors jobs turned in by Greg Kinnear as Simeon.
- Moving portrayal of a homosexual and how they interact with an ill-natured neighbor. Its all about breaking down the walls and seeing the humanity in someone else. This sub-plot is BRILLIANTLY handled. I bought it hook, line and sinker. Wanna learn how you can take your romantic comedy and deal with contemporary, polarizing issues and handle it all in a tactful way? Well then "As Good as It Gets" is a must-see move.
- Great theme, where the character arcs of the two leads bring them to each other to satisfy a clearly defined inner need they both become aware that they now have.
- GREAT use of a dog, Simeon's Verdell is awesome. Best use of a dog in a movie I can remember ever. And director James L. Brooks totally nailed when he gives us a low angle shot of Verdell when he's in the room with Melvin.
For my money, "As Good as It Gets" IS textbook perfection, as far as romantic comedy movies go. You can learn a lot from watching this movie. And it just might even be the ticket for you to now realize that a romantic comedy can be about more than just the coupling of a two people trying a foray into a romance together. "As Good as It Gets" gives the audience a take into how two people of very different mindsets can see the good in others, and reach a happier state of illuminated existence--and this is from a rom-com! Can you believe that!!!
"As Good as It Gets" indeed lives up to its name, and is in my book textbook perfection!